LISA vs Help to Buy ISA: Which Is Better for First-Time Buyers?

If you're saving for your first home today, the LISA is the only one of the two you can open: you can no longer open a Help to Buy ISA. But if you already hold one, comparing the two is worth doing - you might move to a LISA. Here's how they stack up, with the numbers you need to make the right decision.
Why the Help to Buy ISA Closed (And What It Means for You)
The Help to Buy ISA offered a 25% government top-up on your savings, up to a maximum bonus of £3,000, when you buy your first home. You could pay in up to £200 a month. The bonus is paid when you buy - your solicitor or conveyancer applies for it.
New accounts can no longer be opened. Gov.uk now points new savers to the Lifetime ISA (LISA) instead.
If you already hold a Help to Buy ISA, you can keep paying in until November 2029 and claim your bonus until November 2030 - even though new savers can't open one anymore. The home must cost up to £250,000, or up to £450,000 in London.
The Lifetime ISA: The Replacement (And Why It's More Generous)
The LISA is open to new savers. It works like this:
The deal: Save up to £4,000 per tax year (your own savings - your partner can have their own LISA). The government adds 25% - up to £1,000 a year. So £4,000 in = £5,000 total. You can keep paying in and earning the bonus until you're 50.
Who can use it: You must be 18 or over but under 40 to open one, and make your first payment before you're 40. You can use it for your first home (costing £450,000 or less, with no minimum price) or save it for later life. You can withdraw without a charge from age 60.
Key advantage over Help to Buy ISA: The Help to Buy ISA bonus only arrives when you buy, so it never earns interest or growth while you save. With a LISA, ask your provider when the bonus is added - once it's in your account it earns interest or growth alongside your own savings.
Head-to-Head: LISA vs Help to Buy ISA
Let's compare them with real numbers. Imagine you're saving for 3 years before you buy:
| Factor | LISA | Help to Buy ISA |
|---|---|---|
| Max contribution/year | £4,000 | £2,400 (£200/month) |
| Government bonus/year | Up to £1,000 (25%) | Up to £600 (25%) |
| Bonus timing | Added while you save (check provider) | Paid at purchase |
| Max bonus by 3-year purchase | £3,000 | £1,800 |
| Tax-free growth | Yes | Yes |
| Interest rates | Variable (cash) or fund growth (stocks) | Cash only |
| Minimum property price | None | None |
| Maximum property price | £450,000 | £250,000 (£450,000 in London) |
| Age limit | Open aged 18-39 | Not applicable (closed) |
| ISA allowance (total) | £20,000/year | £20,000/year |
| Opened to new applicants | Yes | No (closed) |
The LISA wins in three ways:
1. Higher annual bonus: up to £1,000 vs £600 per year. Over 5 years, that's £5,000 vs £3,000 (and the Help to Buy ISA bonus is capped at £3,000 in total) - a £2,000 difference before interest even arrives.
2. Better compounding: Help to Buy ISA bonuses only arrive at purchase, so they don't earn anything while you save. Any LISA bonus already in your account earns interest or growth alongside your contributions.
3. Higher price limit outside London: LISA works for homes up to £450,000 anywhere. The Help to Buy ISA limit is £250,000 outside London - a real barrier for first-time buyers in pricier areas.
Should You Switch From Help to Buy ISA to LISA?
If you already have a Help to Buy ISA, your switching decision depends on timing:
If you're buying within the next year: Stick with the Help to Buy ISA. You must buy at least 12 months after your first LISA payment to use it for a home, so a new LISA may not be ready in time.
If you're saving for 2+ more years: Run the numbers. If you can afford to contribute £4,000/year instead of £2,400, the LISA bonus starts pulling ahead. But remember the key rule: you can hold both, but you can only use the government bonus from one of them to buy your first home.
The mechanics: You can transfer a Help to Buy ISA into a Lifetime ISA. Moving money the other way (Lifetime ISA to Help to Buy ISA) means paying the 25% withdrawal charge. Your ISA provider (usually your bank) handles a transfer. Check with them about how it works.
Our first-time buyer guide covers the full rules for opening a LISA, and comparing accounts comes down to understanding how tax-free wrappers work - see ISA vs savings account to see why that matters.
Real-World Scenario: The First-Time Buyer's Choice
Picture this: You're 28, earning £35,000, with £8,000 already saved in a Help to Buy ISA. You plan to buy in 3 years. Here's what the two paths look like (ignoring interest):
Path 1: Stay with Help to Buy ISA
- Your current balance: £8,000 (no bonus yet - it is paid when you buy)
- New contributions: £200/month × 36 months = £7,200
- Total savings: £15,200
- Bonus at purchase: 25% of £15,200 = £3,800, capped at £3,000
- Total at purchase: £15,200 + £3,000 = £18,200 (home up to £250,000, or £450,000 in London)
Path 2: Keep the Help to Buy ISA, pay new money into a LISA
- New contributions: £4,000/year × 3 years = £12,000
- New bonuses: up to £1,000/year × 3 years = £3,000
- LISA at purchase: £12,000 + £3,000 = £15,000
- Plus your £8,000 Help to Buy ISA savings, without its bonus (only one bonus can be used)
- Total at purchase: £23,000 (home up to £450,000)
In this scenario both paths earn £3,000 of bonus. Path 2 gives you a bigger deposit and a higher price limit, but you pay in £4,800 more of your own money. If you're starting fresh with no Help to Buy ISA, the LISA is the only option.
For detailed affordability checks, see if your bank's tools or our related cash ISA vs stocks and shares ISA guide help you decide whether to take on cash deposits or growth-focused funds within your LISA.
The Tax Efficiency Question: Why ISAs Matter
Both LISA and Help to Buy ISA are tax-free. That means:
- Interest you earn is not taxable.
- Fund growth (if you choose a stocks and shares LISA) is not taxable.
For many savers the tax saving on interest is small at first. But the structure matters: instead of paying tax on interest earned outside an ISA, you pay £0. Your money compounds untouched.
This is why ISA vs savings account is a question worth asking, and why the ISA allowance (£20,000 a year in 2026-27 across all ISAs) is a ceiling worth using. Your LISA payments count towards that £20,000.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I have a LISA and a Help to Buy ISA at the same time? Yes, you can hold both. But you can only use the government bonus from one of them to buy your first home. You can also transfer your Help to Buy ISA into a Lifetime ISA.
What if I don't buy a property? Do I lose the LISA bonus? If you withdraw for any reason other than buying your first home, reaching 60, or terminal illness, you pay a 25% withdrawal charge on the amount you take out. That recovers the bonus and a bit more: withdraw a £5,000 pot (£4,000 savings + £1,000 bonus) and the charge is £1,250, leaving £3,750 - less than you paid in. The alternative: keep it open as a retirement pot and withdraw from 60 with no charge.
Can I use my LISA bonus if I'm buying above £450,000? Not without a charge. Gov.uk says that if the property costs more than £450,000, you'll pay a 20% withdrawal charge, and there's no charge for properties costing £450,000 and under. Check gov.uk/lifetime-isa for the full conditions. You can keep the account for retirement savings instead.
How much can I contribute to my LISA each year? Up to £4,000 per tax year (6 April to 5 April). The government adds 25%, so the max bonus is £1,000 per year. You can contribute weekly, monthly, or as a lump sum - it doesn't matter as long as the total for the tax year stays at or below £4,000.
Does the LISA bonus count towards my ISA allowance? The £4,000 you pay in counts towards your £20,000 ISA allowance across all individual savings accounts; the government bonus is added on top. So you can have a £4,000 LISA + another £16,000 in other ISAs (cash, stocks, innovative finance) in the same year.
What interest rate will I get? That depends on the provider. Different banks offer different rates on LISA cash accounts. Some LISAs also come in stocks-and-shares versions with fund growth. Rates change, so compare current offers at your bank or on the Money Helper website before opening.
If I'm buying with my partner, can they also open a LISA? Yes. Each of you can open your own LISA and contribute up to £4,000 per year. That's £8,000 combined + up to £2,000 in bonuses per year. If you both have a Lifetime ISA you can both use your savings and bonuses, as long as you're both first-time buyers and meet the conditions.
What's the time limit for using my LISA bonus? There's no age deadline for using it on a home, but you must make your first payment before 40, and you can only pay in and earn the bonus until 50. You must buy at least 12 months after your first payment, use a conveyancer or solicitor, and buy with a mortgage. You also need to meet the UK residence rules.
Next Steps
- Check your Help to Buy ISA: If you have one, call your bank and ask your current balance and how much bonus you could claim.
- Run the LISA numbers: If you're starting fresh or considering a switch, calculate 3 or 5 years of £4,000 contributions + 25% bonus and compare it to where you'd be with Help to Buy ISA.
- Pick your provider: Different banks offer different rates and fund options. Check gov.uk/lifetime-isa for the rules before you choose.
- Set up a regular contribution: £333.33/month into your LISA gets you to the £4,000/year limit and the full £1,000 bonus (a flat £333 a month comes to £3,996).
For related first-time buyer decisions, explore whether you should prioritise tax-free accounts - cash ISA vs stocks and shares ISA shows how risk appetite shapes your returns, and our first-time buyer guide covers the full journey from deposit to completion.